Jump To Navigation
Offshoreinjuries.com En Español   Offshoreinjuries.com in English

Case Law

  • View as PDF
  • E-mail This Link
  • Print

In re DELAWARE BAY LAUCH SERVICE, INC.

Date Decided: July 20th, 2010
Originally Filed in: Delaware (federal)
Decided by: (Federal)
Court: U.S.D.C. for the D. of Delaware
Judge: Farnan
Citation: In re DELAWARE BAY LAUCH SERVICE, 2010 WL 2898296 (D. Del.)

Background:

Plaintiff, a Greek seamen, was injured when he fell into the water while attempting to board a vessel located off the shore of Delaware.  Plaintiff brought claims against the vessel in rem and related shipping interests under the Jones Act and the General Maritime Law.  All named defendants had Greek origins: the vessel sailed under the Greek flag, and other defendants were either Greek Corporations or had their principal place of business in Greece.  The plaintiff/seaman's employment contract contained a forum selection and choice of law clause, naming Greece as the exclusive forum and Greek Law as controlling.  The defendants filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that the Jones Act and general maritime law were inapplicable because Greek law governed the action.  Defendants requested the Court decline its jurisdiction based on the doctrine of forum non conveniens and the Supreme Court decision Canada Malting Co. Ltd v. Patterson Steamships, Ltd., 285 U.S. 413 (1932).  Plaintiff brought a Motion to Compel Discovery, arguing that the discovery he sought was necessary to respond to the defendant's motion to dismiss.


Issues:

Whether the court should grant a motion to dismiss, based on the doctrine of forum non conveniens in an admiralty case, when the plaintiff asserts that discovery is necessary to respond to the defendant's motion to dismiss?


Held:

The court granted the plaintiff's motion to compel discovery and denied the defendants' motion to dismiss with leave to renew.  The court reasoned that although American courts have declined to exercise jurisdiction over cases in which American law does not apply, a full evaluation of the parties' contacts was necessary to determine whether American law applied to the case.  Thus, the court concluded that a full evaluation of the parties' contacts could not be undertaken without further discovery. 


Comments:
A court will compel discovery to determine whether a defendant has sufficient contacts with the United States before it will dismiss the case for forum non conveniens even though the plaintiff's contract contains a foreign law and forum clause.  

<< PREVNEXT >>

In re DELAWARE BAY LAUCH SERVICE, INC.

Overall issues discussed or touched upon by this case:
Free Case Evaluation Form | Talk to a Lawyer Now

NOTE: Labels in bold are required.

  1. disclaimer
In-depth overview Jones Act Click Here

LATEST CASE LAWS

Floyd Badeaux v. Magnolia Fleet, L.L.C., et al.

Date Decided: Feb 25th, 2011
Decided By: Louisiana Eastern District Court (Federal) read more

In the Matter of the Complaint of Pride Offshore, Inc.

Date Decided: Feb 2nd, 2011
Decided By: Texas Southern District Court (Federal) read more

Subscribe to Case Law Feed

LATEST BLOG NEWS

Coast Guard Searches for Dustin Danos Crewman Missing in Gulf of Mexico

 

NEW ORLEANS, La. — The U.S. Coast Guard sent out a news release that they and commercial crews are searching for a miss... read more

Barge Loaded With Fuel Runs Aground in Ft. Point N.H. Outside Portsmouth Harbor

 

FT. POINT, N.H. — A barge loaded with diesel fuel that ran aground in Ft. Point N.H.Ā outside Portsmouth Harbor l... read more

Barge Worker Killed in Conveyor Belt Accident

 

LUDINGTON, MI — Officials reported that a 37-year-old Pentwater man was killed after being tangled in equipment onboar... read more

U.S. Coast Guard Frees Two Double Skin Oil Barges Grounded in Galveston, TX

 

GALVESTON, Texas — The U.S. Coast Guard issued a news release stating that the two double-skinned barges, loaded w... read more

Subscribe to Blog News Feed
Attorneys Refer your cases here

Toll-Free: 800-773-6770
Local: 713-668-9999
Fax: 713-668-1980
1811 Bering Drive, Suite 300
Houston, TX 77057
E-Mail Us | Directions
Se Habla Español